The glow of the television paints the room in flickering blues and greys. Outside, the world sleeps, but here, in the late-night hours fueled by the whir of a VCR, a familiar paranoia creeps back in. It whispers that the danger wasn't averted, merely delayed. That they are still among us, their chillingly patient plan unfolding just beneath the surface of our mundane reality. This is the uneasy promise held within the chunky plastic clamshell of The Second Arrival, a promise that maybe, just maybe, the nightmare wasn't over.
Sequel Shadows and Lowered Sights
Let's be honest, finding this one on the shelf back in '98 likely sparked a mix of excitement and apprehension. David Twohy's original The Arrival (1996) was a genuinely smart, tense sci-fi thriller, punching well above its weight with Charlie Sheen delivering a surprisingly frazzled, compelling performance. Seeing a sequel materialize, especially one premiering on HBO before hitting video stores, felt like both a blessing and a potential curse. Could it recapture that lightning in a bottle? The absence of Sheen and Twohy (though he retains a story credit, the screenplay duties fell to Mark David Perry) immediately sets expectations. Instead, we get Zane Zaminsky's estranged half-brother, Jack Addison, played by Patrick Muldoon (Starship Troopers, Melrose Place), stepping into the breach. It's a tall order, replacing the desperate energy of the original's protagonist.
Paranoia Redux, Familiar Frights
The core concept remains potent: the covert alien invaders are still executing their plan to terraform Earth, accelerating global warming to make our world hospitable for their kind. Jack, a computer expert initially skeptical of his half-brother's warnings (delivered via posthumous videotape – a classic 90s plot device!), stumbles into the conspiracy alongside journalist Bridget Riordan (Jane Sibbett, forever recognisable as Carol from Friends, here playing it straight). The film tries hard to replicate the original's sense of creeping dread, the feeling that anyone could be an agent of the enemy, their true forms hidden beneath disturbingly articulated human disguises. There are moments where it almost clicks – clandestine meetings in shadowy locations, desperate chases, the unsettling click-clack of those reversed alien knees – but the tension often feels thinner, the reveals less impactful. Muldoon brings a certain square-jawed competence, but lacks the raw, unraveling panic that made Sheen's Zane so watchable.
Tenney's Touch in a Twohy World
Handing the directorial reins to Kevin S. Tenney is an interesting footnote. Known primarily for his solid 80s horror entries like Witchboard (1986) and the cult favourite Night of the Demons (1988), Tenney brings a certain workmanlike efficiency to the proceedings. You can sense his attempt to inject atmosphere, particularly in the scenes revealing the aliens' hidden infrastructure. The production, largely filmed in Montreal to stretch the undoubtedly tighter budget (a far cry from the original's reported $25 million), manages some reasonably slick visuals for a direct-to-video/HBO premiere feature of the time. The CGI, while dated now, likely felt adequate flickering on our CRT screens, and there are still a few moments where the alien designs retain a sliver of their unsettling power. The presence of veteran actor Michael Sarrazin (They Shoot Horses, Don't They?) lends a touch of gravitas as a potential ally, his weary presence hinting at deeper secrets. Yet, despite Tenney's efforts, the film rarely escapes the shadow of its predecessor or the inherent limitations of its DTV origins. The pacing sometimes stumbles, and the plot beats feel more like echoes than fresh revelations.
Echoes in the Static
Watching The Second Arrival today is a curious experience. It's a product of its time – that late-90s wave of sci-fi thrillers trying to cash in on The X-Files zeitgeist, often landing directly on video store shelves. It competently ticks the boxes: the reluctant hero, the plucky female reporter, the shadowy conspiracy, the global threat. It doesn't embarrass itself, and for fans of the original, it offered something more, a continuation, however diluted. Did the slightly clunky dialogue or the sometimes predictable plot twists bother us as much back then, when simply having another chapter felt like enough? Perhaps not. There's a certain comfort in its familiarity, even if it lacks the sharp edges and genuine surprises of the first film. It functions as a decent, if unremarkable, expansion of the core concept, reminding us that the fight against the hidden invaders was far from over.
---
Rating: 5/10
Justification: The Second Arrival delivers a competent, watchable sci-fi thriller narrative that adequately continues the premise of the original. Patrick Muldoon is serviceable, and Kevin S. Tenney's direction keeps things moving. However, it lacks the tension, originality, and stronger character work of the 1996 film, often feeling like a derivative retread hampered by its direct-to-video constraints and less impactful effects. It earns points for trying and for featuring genre stalwart Michael Sarrazin, but ultimately remains firmly in the shadow of its superior predecessor.
Final Thought: A quintessential late-90s DTV sequel – not essential viewing, but a mildly diverting slice of sci-fi paranoia for those nights when you just wanted another dose of alien conspiracy, straight from the flickering heart of VHS Heaven.