The flickering static clears, the tracking adjusts, and that familiar production company logo swims into view. Sometimes, the most unsettling darkness doesn't lurk in shadowed castles or deep space, but behind the picket fences of sun-drenched suburbia. Some dangers wear the most disarming smiles. Remember that feeling? The slow-burn dread of watching someone charming turn possessive, obsessive, dangerous? 1993’s The Crush bottled that specific brand of unease, presenting a chilling portrait of adolescent infatuation curdling into something truly toxic, all wrapped up in the glossy aesthetics of the early 90s.
Innocence Weaponized
The setup feels almost idyllic, classic thriller fodder. Journalist Nick Eliot (Cary Elwes, shedding his heroic The Princess Bride (1987) persona for something far more vulnerable) moves to a new city for a promising job at Pique magazine. He rents a charming guest house owned by the Forrester family, seemingly hitting the jackpot. But the Forresters' daughter, the 14-year-old Adrian… no, Darian (Alicia Silverstone), is anything but typical. Initially presenting as precociously intelligent, witty, and strikingly beautiful, her attention towards Nick quickly shifts from flirtatious admiration to a suffocating, calculated obsession. What starts as playful notes and lingering glances spirals into sabotage, false accusations, and outright violence. The film masterfully plays on the initial disbelief – surely this charming young girl can’t be that dangerous? But oh, she is.
A Star is Born… and She's Terrifying
Let's be honest, the gravitational center of The Crush is Alicia Silverstone. In her feature film debut, filmed when she was just 16, she delivers a performance that remains startlingly effective. She embodies Darian's dangerous duality perfectly – the flicker of vulnerability beneath the manipulative scheming, the chilling blankness in her eyes when crossed. It wasn't just puppy love; it was predatory. Silverstone reportedly beat out numerous other actresses for the role, with director Alan Shapiro fighting hard for her casting. It paid off. She swept the 1994 MTV Movie Awards, winning both Breakthrough Performance and Best Villain, instantly announcing her arrival. Doesn't that performance still feel unnervingly magnetic, even knowing where it's headed? It’s a testament to her raw talent that she could project such complex, unsettling maturity at that age.
Suburban Nightmare Fuel
Alan Shapiro, who also penned the script, crafts a surprisingly tense atmosphere despite the bright, often sunny visuals typical of the setting (Vancouver skillfully doubling for generic American suburbia). The horror isn't derived from jump scares, but from the relentless psychological warfare Darian wages. Nick’s growing isolation, his helplessness as his life is systematically dismantled by a seemingly untouchable teenager, creates a palpable sense of dread. The film cleverly uses Nick's profession – a writer seeking truth – against him, as Darian twists narratives and plants false evidence with terrifying ease. We see his frustration mount, his reputation crumble, all while Darian maintains her facade of injured innocence to everyone else. There’s a claustrophobia to his situation, trapped in that guest house, increasingly wary of the girl next door.
Retro Fun Facts: More Than Meets the Eye
Beyond Silverstone's breakout, The Crush has its share of intriguing footnotes. You might recall the whispers back then – the film faced a lawsuit from Amy Fisher, the infamous "Long Island Lolita," who claimed the story mirrored her own highly publicized case involving attempted murder stemming from an affair with an older man. While Shapiro maintained the script predated the Fisher headlines, the real-world echo added an uncomfortable layer of notoriety upon release. The film, made for around $14 million, didn’t exactly set the box office ablaze, earning just under $13.6 million domestically. However, like so many films of its ilk, it found a robust second life on VHS and cable, becoming a staple of late-night viewing and sleepovers, solidifying its cult status among 90s thriller fans. I distinctly remember seeing that provocative VHS cover art staring out from the rental store shelf, hinting at the forbidden allure within.
Aging Gracefully? Or Just Aging?
Watching The Crush today inevitably reveals some wrinkles. The pacing can feel a little deliberate by modern standards, and some plot mechanics might stretch credulity. Jennifer Rubin as Nick’s photographer colleague and potential love interest feels somewhat underutilized, mainly serving as another pawn in Darian’s game. Yet, the core discomfort remains potent. The film taps into genuine anxieties about reputation, the violation of personal space, and the terrifying potential for harm hidden beneath a veneer of normalcy. While the "psycho stalker" trope became ubiquitous in the 90s (think Single White Female (1992) or Fear (1996)), The Crush's specific angle – the predator being a teenage girl exploiting societal assumptions about youth and innocence – gives it a unique, lingering chill.
---
VHS Heaven Rating: 7/10
Justification: The Crush overcomes some familiar 90s thriller plotting with a genuinely unsettling atmosphere and, crucially, a star-making, iconic performance from Alicia Silverstone. Her portrayal of Darian elevates the material significantly, making the threat feel chillingly real. Cary Elwes is effective as the increasingly desperate target, and the film successfully generates palpable dread. While not perfect, its central performance and potent premise earn it a solid score, reflecting its effectiveness as a psychological thriller that definitely left an impression back in the VHS days, even if some elements feel dated now.
Final Thought: It's a film that reminds you that sometimes the most dangerous monsters aren't lurking in the shadows, but smiling right at you in broad daylight – a chilling little gem from the racks of the video store that proved innocence could be the most terrifying mask of all.